There’s No Yuletide Without Theatre Three’s “A Christmas Carol.”
There’s No Yuletide Without Theatre Three’s “A Christmas Carol.”
By Cindi Sansone-Braff
Photos: Steve Ayle
Christmastime is about tradition and sharing time-tested holiday rituals with family and friends, like shopping for a tree, making a gingerbread house, hanging decorations, and visiting Santa. For Long Islanders, to miss Theatre Three’s annual production of Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” is pure humbug and gosh-darn sacrilegious.
“A Christmas Carol, in Prose: Being a Ghost Story of Christmas,” published on December 19, 1843, was the first Yuletide story written by the legendary English author. In the twenty-five years following its publication, Dickens wrote dozens more, including, “The Haunted Man and the Ghost’s Bargain: A Fancy for Christmas Time,” and “The Chimes: A Goblin Story of Some Bells that Rang an Old Year Out and a New Year In.”
A yearly pilgrimage to Theatre Three’s “A Christmas Carol” reminds us of the two-fold message inherent in this beloved tale of redemption. Firstly, anyone can experience a miraculous change of heart. Secondly, all of us must give ourselves a yearly “life review,” where we take a good, hard look at our words, deeds, and actions to see what we learned and what we can do better in the upcoming year.
Theatre Three’s Executive Artistic Director Jeffrey Sanzel’s brilliant adaptation, precision-perfect direction, and unforgettable portrayal of Scrooge are the heart and soul of this stellar production. Each year, Sanzel brings an additional layer of depth to his remarkable performance. One of the show’s high points is watching Sanzel’s intense body language and facial expressions as he brings the misanthropic, miserable, and miserly character of Ebenezer Scrooge to life and then witnessing his entire demeanor morph as he reveals the kind, generous, and grateful soul Scrooge becomes.
The production opens on an eerily dark note, with the somber echoes of the lines, “Marley was dead … There is no doubt about that.” With that thought solidly planted in our heads, Stephen T. Wangner delivers a bloodcurdling performance as the ghost of Jacob Marley, chained and remorseful as he returns from the depths of hell. This Christmas classic teems with ghosts, including the Ghost of Christmas Past, angelically portrayed by the talented Cassidy Rose O’Brien. The role of the Ghost of Christmas Present demands an actor who can deliver his clever and well-crafted lines with perfect comedic timing, and Scott Hofer rocked this role. The most terrifying specter of all is the humongous Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. Expertly maneuvering this larger-than-life costume was Steven Uihlein.
Throughout the show, Dickens offers much-needed comedic relief in this otherwise dark portrait of the hardship of life in London during the Victorian era. Two of his most endearingly witty characters are the lovable Mr. Fezziwig, Scrooge’s first employer, and his jovial wife, Mrs. Fezziwig. Scott Hofer and Ginger Dalton’s charismatic portrayal of this happily married couple was one of the show’s highlights. Dalton was also outstanding as Scrooge’s hilarious housekeeper, Mrs. Dilber.
Other notable performers were Julia Albino as Belle, Fezziwig’s dutiful daughter, who reluctantly breaks off her engagement to Scrooge; Kyle Breitenbach as Dick Wilkins, Fezziwig’s apprentice; Steven Uihlein as Fred Halliwell, Scrooge’s kind nephew, and Cassidy Rose O’Brien as Janet Halliwell.
Ray Gobes, Jr. brought great warmth and kindness to the role of Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s long-suffering employee. Linda May delivered an award-worthy performance as Cratchit’s loving wife and mother of his children. May has a beautiful singing voice, which she showcased during her moving solo. Much of this allegorical tale’s emotional appeal comes from the heartwarming scenes featuring the tight-knit Cratchit clan. The young actors who portrayed their children were outstanding, including Mia Rofrano as Martha, Aidan Sharkey as Peter, and Angelina Eybs as Belinda. Stanley Zinger delivered a heartrending portrayal of one of Dickens’ most beloved characters—Tiny Tim.
Saturday night’s opening performance featured the children from “The Holly Cast.” Kathleen Anabelle Han gave a captivating performance as The Girl, whose muted presence haunts Scrooge. Patrick Hutchison aced the role of Scrooge as a lonely schoolboy, and Zachery Kanakaris was charming as the elated child on Christmas morning. Ash Stalker delivered a memorable performance as Fan, Scrooge’s older sister, and Amelia Theodorakis commanded the stage as Margaret and the Charwoman. Alternating performances feature another talented group of child actors known as “The Ivy Cast,” which includes Vivian Leigh Rumble, Giovanni Ladd, Olivia Davis, Christina Gobes, Kelsie Curran, Jennifer Salvia, Roy Fleischer, Skye Greenberg, and James Bressler.
A great deal of the success of this production goes to the top-notch creative team. Special mention goes out to Sari Feldman for her expert choreography, Ellen Michelmore for her original music and sound effects design, Tim Haggerty for his exceptional sound design, and Robert W. Henderson, Jr. for his spectacular lighting and sound design. The breathtaking set by Randall Parsons, the authentic Victorian-period costumes by Jason Allyn and Randall Parsons, and Brad Frey’s astute musical direction all came together to make “A Christmas Carol” a resounding success.
This magical, musical, mystical show is a visceral experience. You will laugh. You will cry, and you will gasp in abject horror. Ultimately, you will leave Theatre Three vowing to keep the Christmas spirit always in your heart.
Arrive early to enjoy the cast caroling on the Second Stage and stay afterward to take an onstage picture with Ebenezer Scrooge. Surprising your friends and family with tickets to Theatre Three’s superb production of “A Christmas Carol” is the perfect holiday gift! The show runs through December 28, 2024. For tickets, call the box office at 631-928-9100 or visit www.theatrethree.com.
Cindi Sansone-Braff is an award-winning playwright. She has a BFA in Theatre from UCONN and is a member of the Dramatists Guild. She is the author of “Grant Me a Higher Love,” “Why Good People Can’t Leave Bad Relationships,” and “Confessions of a Reluctant Long Island Psychic.” Her full-length Music Drama, “Beethoven, The Man, The Myth, The Music,” is published by Next Stage Press. www.Grantmeahigherlove.com.